EXCLUSIVE: Aldair Reflects on Brazil's Struggles, Neymar's Return, and the Totti-Ronaldo Debate
A USA '94 World Cup champion and a revered figure in football history, former Brazilian defender Aldair shared his insights in a candid interview. He discussed the criticisms surrounding an underperforming Selecao, the eagerly awaited return of Neymar, and his enduring connection with Roma, along with the Giallorossi's Scudetto aspirations under Gian Piero Gasperini, and Benfica's current form.
In addition to offering his perspective on modern football and the new documentary chronicling his life, Aldair regaled Flashscore with a delightful anecdote about two football legends he played alongside: Francesco Totti and Ronaldo.
How do you assess Brazil's opening match against Morocco?
“I watched the game and felt there were too many misplaced passes; Brazil's performance was far from satisfactory. They looked really, really poor! I expect much more, just like everyone else back home!”
What are your thoughts on Ancelotti's management?
“Regarding this match, we didn't see his influence. They performed a bit better in the friendlies, but in this World Cup opener, his work was scarcely evident. Perhaps the substitutions were a positive, but other than that, we saw very little.”
Who do you believe can step up and lead the team during this tough time?
“There are several players expected to rise to the occasion. Raphinha, although he hasn't been in form with the national team lately, and Vinicius, who showed improvement in one match, come to mind. Of course, there's always hope that Neymar will embrace this responsibility.”
What is your opinion on Neymar's recall to the national team?
“I believe it's the right decision because he's an exceptional player, distinct from the others. It’s wise of Ancelotti to include him and allow him to regain full fitness. Calling him up was certainly not a mistake.”
The World Cup now features 48 teams. What do you think about such an expanded tournament?
“This expansion allows many more countries the chance to compete in a World Cup, which is a beautiful opportunity. However, it also highlights significant disparities in skill. We've seen shocking results, like Spain drawing against Cape Verde, who are making their debut. Conversely, stronger teams like Germany capitalizing on these mismatches, as seen in their 7-0 rout of Curacao. Ultimately, the path to the knockout stages, especially for the top two spots, will be determined by the clashes between traditional powerhouses and these smaller nations, especially in terms of goal difference.”
You participated in three World Cups and won in '94. What are your memories of that victory?
“Winning a World Cup is truly exhilarating, but for me, just participating in one is a remarkable experience. I fondly remember Italia '90, even though I didn’t play a minute. The tournaments in America and France hold special memories for me as well. Competing in this event is the pinnacle for every footballer. From USA '94, I recall nearly every moment on the pitch. Today, there's so much more information available about off-pitch events in the host country; these are valuable lessons for today's players.”
A documentary about your life has premiered in Italy. How did this project come about, and what is it like to see yourself on the big screen?
“This project was initiated by three friends from Rome who are passionate Roma fans. After several discussions, they convinced me to share my story beyond football. We filmed for a year across Rome, Dubai, and Brazil, working diligently on the project. Although my natural shyness made it a bit challenging, we managed to create something meaningful that reveals a side of me that fans and the public may not have known.”
How do you explain the immense affection Roma fans have for you?
“I get asked this often. It feels as though I was born in footballing terms at Roma, even though that’s not entirely true. The fans' love for me is immense. I spent many years there, and to them, it feels like I started my career there as a young player and played my entire career at the club!”
You played alongside both Totti and Ronaldo, 'Il Fenomeno'. Who do you consider the better player?
“They are two distinct players. Ronaldo was an explosive one-on-one striker, while Francesco excelled in the box with a keen eye for both passing and scoring. Choosing the best is tough; the ideal scenario would have been to have them both on the same team, eliminating the need to choose. I remember returning to Rome after the '94 World Cup, where everyone talked about Brazil’s number 9. People at Trigoria were saying, 'Look, we have our own Ronaldo here too,' referring to a young Francesco Totti. Then Francesco showcased his talent, and I was genuinely thrilled for him.”
Do you still keep an eye on your first European club, Benfica? What are your thoughts on their current situation?
“I don’t follow them as closely as I used to, but this year, with Mourinho in charge, I've watched more of their matches. In recent years, Benfica has struggled; they often find themselves in crisis and fail to perform to their potential in Europe. The squad has some promising players, but they are still searching for significant results.”
What are your impressions of Gasperini’s Roma? Can they compete for the title?
“Gasperini’s football philosophy is very promising. The first year in Rome can be challenging for anyone, but he has done remarkably well, delivering a truly spectacular season. To advance further, however, the club needs to strengthen the squad and bring in some additional talent. If Roma secures the players he desires, they will certainly be in contention with the top teams for the Scudetto.”
As we await to see if Ancelotti's Selecao can find their rhythm to aim for the pinnacle of this World Cup, and whether Gasperini’s Roma will receive the necessary reinforcements to challenge for the Scudetto, fans can look forward to experiencing the most intimate and unseen facets of this Brazilian legend on the big screen.
